Oven or Airfryer, experts weigh in and their verdict will surprise you

 

A countertop craze promises convenience, while a kitchen mainstay keeps its loyalists. Where do the tradeoffs really land for busy cooks, and what should guide your choice when both options seem right?

Air fryers are edging into everyday cooking, challenging the old dominance of the traditional oven. The pitch is simple: concentrated hot air, fast results, little oil. The real test sits elsewhere: how they compare on cooking time, energy use, and capacity. Specialists examine where each appliance excels, and how the recipe and portion size should shape the choice.

the rise of the air fryer

By dinnertime, Dutch kitchens hum with a new favorite: the air fryer. The compact box promises crisp fries, quick chicken, and fewer splatters, all powered by fast-moving hot air instead of oil. It fits on a counter, heats in minutes, and invites weeknight spontaneity. But can a countertop gadget really replace a full oven?

benefits of the air fryer

The air fryer’s calling card is speed. Preheating is minimal and cook times are short, which matters on busy nights or when you only need 1–2 portions. France’s energy agency ADEME reports that for small loads an air fryer often uses less energy than a traditional oven. The compact cavity concentrates heat and airflow, producing crisp textures without a vat of oil.

limits of the air fryer

Trade-offs start with capacity. Most baskets comfortably serve 1–2 people, and stacking food reduces browning. Classic oven features are also missing or limited: top-down broiling, steady top-and-bottom heat, and reliable multi-shelf baking. Try a deep lasagna or a loaf of bread and you will meet those constraints quickly; the basket’s shape and height simply leave less room to rise, dome, or brown evenly.

what experts say

Chefs and energy specialists land on a nuanced verdict. For small, fast jobs, an air fryer is efficient and consistently crisp; for breadth and volume, the oven still wins. ADEME notes that a well-used oven—especially with strong convection—becomes efficient when fully loaded, often allowing a set temperature about 20 degrees lower while maintaining even results. That same oven also unlocks versatility: sheet-pan dinners, multiple trays of cookies, grilled vegetables under direct top heat, and bread with proper oven spring.

the right tool for every kitchen

Choosing between the two depends on how you cook and for how many. If you live solo or cook for 2, the air fryer covers snacks, frozen items, and quick proteins with minimal fuss. For family meals, large casseroles, careful baking, or cooking several components at once, the oven remains essential. In many homes, they complement each other: the air fryer handles speed; the oven handles scope and precision.

Daniel Brooks
Written by Daniel Brooks

Daniel Brooks is a home and garden writer with a passion for practical living and outdoor spaces. He writes about gardening, home improvement and everyday solutions, helping readers create functional, welcoming homes and healthier gardens.